If you are trying to create a landing page you may have found yourself debating on which landing page builder you want to go with. Will it be ConvertKit or LeadPages? How do you choose?
While they are both great tools, in this post, I will determine which is better, ConvertKit vs LeadPages? But before I do that I want to talk a little about what I think goes into a great tool to create lead pages.
What goes into a great lead page tool?
If you have a blog, you need to have lead and sales pages. And you want a tool that will help you be successful in doing that.
Here are the things I think a great landing page builder should include:
- Split Testing Abilities
- Detailed Reporting
- Page and form templates
- Variety of different conversion tools
- Ability to connect to other tools in your funnel
- Ease of Use
I do want to start by saying that Convertkit is an Email Marketing Automation tool, but it does have the functionality to create lead pages for lead generation as well. so keep this in mind when it comes to my analysis of both tools!
Split Testing Abilities
Being able to do split testing—aka A/B testing—with your landing page tool is a pretty important feature. Having this ability allows you to try out different things on your pages to see what works and what does not.
Missing this feature means you might have a page that could be making better conversions for you, but it is hard to know for sure.
LeadPages has a robust A/B testing feature that lets you select two pages you’d like to run side-by-side with one another. And it tells you the conversion rate for each one.
Unfortunately, ConvertKit does not have a split-testing feature for its lead pages. So I think in this particular category, Lead pages is the winner.
Having detailed reporting is probably one of the most important features when it comes to landing pages. If you want to improve your conversion rates, you have to know how many people are visiting your page and of those how many are converting.
And if your lead conversion tool can tell you all of this, even better!
LeadPages gives you a variety of stats to look at when it comes to your landing pages. You can see how many views, unique visitors, conversions, and of course your conversion rate for a particular page.
I especially like that your dashboard also shows you many of these stats at a glance as well.
ConvertKit is more than just an email service. It also has reporting capabilities for its landing pages but does not collect as much data as LeadPages. Instead, they show you visitors, subscribers, and conversion rates. One feature that I love about ConvertKit’s reporting is that they also offer you the top referring links. This is an excellent way to know what traffic sources are working best and whether or not you need a content upgrade.
If I had to pick a winner between the two, I would go with LeadPages, not just because they provide more data with their reporting but also because the data is at the center of the tool. It is prioritized not only on the dashboard but also on the page data itself.
Page and Form Templates
If you are not a web designer, it helps to have page templates ready to go that look great and will convert well. Both ConvertKit and LeadPages offer page templates to choose from.
ConvertKit landing pages have various page and form templates you can use. And they categorize them based on the use you want to use the page for, varying from collecting email subscribers for your newsletter to promoting a lead magnet product for signups.
If I were comparing the sheer number of templates to each other, LeadPages landing page templates would win by a landslide. They have a massive collection of templates and regularly add new ones to the list. My favorite feature when it comes to sorting through the templates is that you can sort them by the highest conversion rate pages. (This is typically what I do when I create pages.)
But you also have the option to sort by color, style, and industry. Honestly, this can be a little overwhelming at times, but it does pay to have this variety when you go in to create a new page.
I will go with LeadPages as the winner here, just because they have more template options and because they tell you which ones have historically had better conversion rates in the past.
Variety of Different Conversion Tools
Can I tell you about one of my favorite features for LeadPages real quick? It’s the fact that they have more than just pages you can use to convert people.
They also do pop-ups, Alert bars, opt-in texts, and trigger links. This may all sound like gibberish, but I was sold when I saw that using LeadPages pop-ups averaged a much higher conversion rate than did my actual landing pages. More like 50-80% conversions compared to my typical 20-30% conversions with pages. And while I did shop around for other lead page tools, none had anything comparable to this.
ConvertKit is very lean on the variety of conversion tools it has since, as I mentioned before, this is an email marketing automation tool first, but you do have a couple of options. You can choose to do a simple form or an actual page. You get tracking data for both.
If you want to get more conversions, I think LeadPages is the way to go in this category. But if your goal is to keep things simple, well then Convertkit may be more your speed. But for the sake of this article, I am going to go with LeadPages.
Ability To Connect To Other Tools
If you are creating lead pages, chances are you are probably using other tools to help you convert them. Whether collecting emails for a webinar with a webinar or connecting to your payment tool, having a variety of integrations is vital for a lead page tool.
In this case, I believe both tools do a fantastic job of connecting to different platforms. They have many they relate to. And if for some reason you do not see a tool you use on this list, both tools work well with Zapier, so you can still connect to other tools with them as a middleman.
I think both tools won for this round.
Ease Of Use
Lastly, you have ease of use. It does not matter how many bells and whistles. A tool is challenging to navigate. I have used both of these tools; ConvertKit and LeadPages, for years, so at this point, they both become user-friendly for me. However, both tools have their pros and cons.
LeadPages has several different widgets, branding elements, and functions you can choose from when building a page. If this is your first time using the builder, it can be pretty darn confusing. You have to click around to see how certain parts work or don’t work. But it is intuitive enough where you can kind of figure out how all of this is supposed to work without watching a bunch of tutorials about it.
Looking at ConvertKit, the ease of use is excellent. If you want to edit a part of the page, click on it. And then you can edit it. So easy. I have created pages on ConvertKit in record time since the pages are so easy to navigate.
And there are not a ton of templates to choose from initially.
Looking at both tools, I would definitely say that ConverKit wins for ease of use because anyone can go and create a landing page within minutes even if you’ve never created one before.
ConvertKit vs Leadpages: Which Is The Winner?
It depends on what you are into.
I am going to be perfectly honest here. They didn’t have landing pages when I originally signed up for ConvertKit. So I had to connect LeadPages to ConvertKit. It was just the way things were done.
So when ConvertKit announced that they would let you build landing pages within their platform, I thought, finally! Now I can cancel my LeadPages subscription.
And then I didn’t.
Sure I could’ve made the switch to ConvertKit only, but the thing is, I loved the detailed reporting and the variety of options I have with LeadPages.
Pros of ConvertKit: Why Choose This Option?
If your goal of creating landing pages is to collect emails to build your list, then ConvertKit is perfectly fine to use. It has a lot of options for its landing pages, especially considering that its main product is email marketing, not landing page creation.
If you want to build your list but feel limited because you cannot afford to also buy a specific lead page building tool like LeadPages, ConvertKit is the right choice for you.
Also, ConvertKit lets you create an account for FREE! So you can create landing pages and grow your email list up to 1,000 subscribers before you have to worry about spending a dime. Or, if you want to access more features upfront, they also have an awesome free trial you can choose from.
If this sounds like the right option for you, sign up here.
Pros of LeadPages: Why Choose This Option?
If you are creating more than just landing pages to build your email list, such as creating your products, then I think LeadPages is the way to go.
You have so much more control over what your pages look like and what is working and what isn’t with detailed reporting that LeadPages is the obvious choice if your goal is to make some cash from the pages you build.
LeadPages comes in many packages too, with the first one starting at only $37 a month if you pay annually.
Where do you land in the ConvertKit vs. LeadPages debate? Tell me all about it in the comments!